Hiển thị các bài đăng có nhãn Policy. Hiển thị tất cả bài đăng
Hiển thị các bài đăng có nhãn Policy. Hiển thị tất cả bài đăng

Chủ Nhật, 12 tháng 5, 2013

From Benghazi to Syria: Obama’s Bush-league mistakes in foreign policy

By Walter Shapiro

Most second-term presidents become fixated on global affairs because the world beyond our shores, with all its strife and misery, often seems more malleable than life in Washington, with its fractious Congress and waning electoral mandate. The trick, though, for a foreign policy president, is to be good at it—and these days those skills appear to be eluding Barack Obama.

This week’s biggest rebuke to Obama foreign policy was not Wednesday’s House hearing on Benghazi with its wrenching narrative of the September night that Ambassador Chris Stevens was killed in Libya. Nor was it Friday morning’s revelation  of new Benghazi-related documents. More embarrassing was a front-page article in last Sunday’s New York Times detailing how Obama erred last August when he impetuously declared that Syria’s use of chemical weapons in its civil war would be a “red line.”

It’s a simple rule: Presidents should never make threats until they have worked out how they would enforce them. But Obama violated it with his stern, but ill-considered warning to Syrian strongman Bashir Assad. The Times article quotes one anonymous top government official claiming, “What Obama said in August was unscripted” and “nuance got completely dropped.” Barry Pavel, a former national security adviser to Obama, said flatly, “I’m not convinced it was thought through.”

Current and former foreign policy advisers usually fall on their swords to protect a president’s reputation for sagacity. Only long afterwards, when the “if only he had listened to me” memoirs are published, do we finally get a glimpse of what really happened in the White House. That’s why it’s telling that Obama insiders are already willing to trash the president for his all-bluster “red line” rhetoric.

The reason for the finger-pointing at Obama is that America is now caught in a loose-lips-create-slips dilemma. Without any good policy options available and a growing isolationist mood among voters, Obama must decide what to do in response to highly probable evidence that forces loyal to Assad used banned chemical weapons. Arming the rebels, many of whom are Islamic militants, carries its own risk, yet doing nothing makes American appear feckless and irresolute.

Playing for time, Obama has been reduced to linguistic hair-splitting. Asked at a Tuesday press conference about perceptions that Syria has crossed his supposed red line, Obama said lamely, “I don't make decisions based on ‘perceived.’ And I can't organize international coalitions around ‘perceived.’ We've tried that in the past, by the way, and it didn't work out well.”

That, of course, was a reference to George W. Bush and his fallacious weapons-of-mass-destruction pretext for the Iraq War. As a presidential candidate, Obama presented himself as the antithesis of this kind of shoot-first foreign policy impetuousness. But, as president, it’s startling how much Obama resembles Bush in many aspects of national security policy.

Take Guantanamo, where currently about 100 of the remaining detainees are waging a hunger strike. Asked at a recent press conference about the Bush-era Cuban detention camp that he has repeatedly vowed to close, Obama sounded more like an outside critic than a president: “It hurts us in terms of international standing. … It is a recruitment tool for extremists. It needs to be closed.”

Despite intermittant efforts by Obama since taking office, Congress has refused to allow the president to close Guantanamo. But that does not make Obama a helpless bystander with no control over this symbolic blot on America’s international reputation.
 
The president has refused to use his existing legal authority (using waivers from the Defense Department) to repatriate 86 low-risk detainees, mostly from Yemen, whose cases have been reviewed by American authorities. Some of these prisoners were rank-and-file al-Qaida soldiers back in 2001 and others were probably picked up by mistake. But today these detainees would be less of a threat sent back in their home countries then they are as enduring symbols of an American Gulag on Guantanamo.

Then there are the drones. Bush may have initiated the airborne assassination program in  2004, but Obama has made it a hallmark of his response to terrorism. With his drone policy, Obama has embraced three of the worst aspects of Bush-era national security policy: an obsession with secrecy; a contorted view of legal norms, especially the definition of “imminent threat”; and a refusal to consider that American tactics may create more terrorists than they kill. In Pakistan alone, based on the best independent statistics, Obama has ordered six times as many drone strikes as ever Bush did.
 
The silence from most Democrats on these troubling aspects of Obama foreign policy has been dispiriting. Had Bush made toothless threats to Syria, force fed prisoners in Guantanamo or rained death from the air in Pakistan on a weekly basis, liberals in Congress would be sputtering with outrage. Instead, with a few conspicuous exceptions—like Oregon Senator Ron Wyden on drones—the dominant feeling appears to be that if Obama does it, it has to be right.

Ever since George McGovern lost 49 states to Richard Nixon in 1972, Democrats have cowered in terror at the thought of being branded as soft on national security. This may partly explain Obama’s timorousness on Guantanamo and the president’s embrace of drone strikes as a way of being tough against terrorists without risking American casualties.

The Republican obsession with Benghazi is rooted in the belief that the Obama administration was reluctant to label the 2012 Libyan attacks as “terrorism” because that would undermine the president’s narrative in an election year. Wednesday’s hearing—built around the testimony of three mid-level State Department officials—failed to prove anything close to causation. On Friday morning, however, ABC News reported that the State Department had insisted references to prior warnings on terrorism should be airbrushed out of the initial CIA talking points on the Banghazi attack.

This was the briefing document that UN Ambassador Susan Rice, who drew the short straw as the administration’s TV talker, relied on when she made the rounds of Sunday-morning interviews the week of the attacks. Now, based on the ABC News story,  it seems clear that Victoria Nuland, a career foreign service officer who was Hillary Clinton’s spokesperson at State, had insisted to the White House that these talking points be watered down.

Even now, so much about Benghazi remains murky, including how big a scandal it will actually prove to be. Were Nuland’s editing suggestions primarily designed to politically protect Obama and Clinton? Or was this, at its core, a Washington bureaucratic battle over which agency should be blamed for the deaths in Libya—State or the CIA?

Security was obviously lax in Benghazi. But was that because Stevens was a fearless diplomat who hated hunkering down behind concrete walls? Or was this related to the CIA’s still-mysterious role on the ground in Benghazi? And did the administration’s self-congratulatory belief in the Libyan revolution play a role in the relaxation of vigilence? Remember, Libya was Obama’s success story from the Arab Spring—the nation where a dictator was toppled by America boldly leading from behind.

Despite the documents discovered by ABC News, my guess is that the tragedy in Benghazi and its muddled aftermath had far more to do with human error than major-league conspiracy. In fact, given the way that Obama has handled his “red line” in Syria, the case for human error seems quite compelling.


View the original article here

Thứ Tư, 24 tháng 4, 2013

Next BoE chief Carney says clear framework key to policy success

OTTAWA (Reuters) - The next Bank of England governor Mark Carney said on Wednesday a key lesson he will bring from Canada to his new job is the need for clear objectives and communication about what exactly the central bank aims to achieve with its policies.

Carney, who steps down as Bank of Canada chief in June to take over at the Bank in July, said that during the 2008-09 recession in Canada, having a well-understood inflation target helped policy makers explain directly to Canadians how they planned to stimulate the economy and boosted confidence.

"I think the core lesson that was reinforced and that I have an even greater appreciation for now than I had when I started as governor, is the importance of having clearly articulated policy frameworks," Carney said when asked what lessons he would bring to the Bank.

"That's not a very snappy thing to say but it's absolutely essential," he said in his testimony to a Senate committee.

Expectations are high for Carney as he gears up for a daunting task: turn around Britain's ailing economy, fix its banks and overhaul the Bank.

Under his watch, Canada's recession was milder than that of the United States or the United Kingdom and it has since recovered. At the height of the crisis, the central bank dropped its key interest rate to an ultra-low level of 0.25 percent and, in its most innovative move, pledged to keep the rate at that level for more than a year unless inflation picked up.

Carney said Bank of Canada officials "reached over the heads of commentators and spoke directly to Canadians" about the low cost of borrowing, persuading them to spend and boost growth.

But the bank never had to resort to unconventional policy such as buying bonds, as done in the U.K., the U.S. and Japan.

Despite the differences with the U.K., Carney stressed that unconventional policy should also be guided by clearly communicated principles and frameworks that the public can understand.

"I prefer not to comment too much on the U.K. but I think the benefit of the institution to which I'm going, one of the benefits, is a tremendous amount of thought has been given ... by the institution itself but ultimately decided by the government and parliamentarians, to the framework that the Bank of England has," he said.

The Bank has much broader powers than the Bank of Canada, encompassing regulation of banks and financial stability as well as monetary policy. Each area of work should have its own separate framework, Carney said.

"And they also have to think through, and they have thought through, how the three of those interact within one institution," he said.

(Reporting by Louise Egan; Editing by Carol Bishopric)


View the original article here

Thứ Ba, 16 tháng 4, 2013

BoE's King stresses limits of monetary policy

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - Monetary policy cannot do all the work of stimulating economic recovery, Bank of England head Mervyn King said on Tuesday.

"There are limits on the ability of monetary policy to stimulate demand," King told a conference sponsored by the International Monetary Fund.

King also said the economy would not rebound firmly as long as banks have too little capital.

The Bank decided not to pump fresh money into its stagnant economy earlier this month, despite a new remit that gives it more leeway to disregard above-target inflation.

(Reporting by Pedro da Costa and Jason Lange)


View the original article here

Thứ Tư, 3 tháng 4, 2013

Bank of England set to keep policy steady despite new remit

By David Milliken

LONDON (Reuters) - The Bank of England is unlikely to pump fresh money into Britain's stagnant economy on Thursday, despite a new remit that gives it extra leeway to disregard above-target inflation.

Chancellor George Osborne tweaked the central bank's mandate two weeks ago, giving it stronger backing to continue ignoring inflation when it overshoots its target due to one-off factors.

But only a handful of economists polled by Reuters last week expect the central bank to add this month to the 375 billion pounds of government bonds it bought between March 2009 and October 2012.

"For as long as you say there is a 2 percent inflation target, I think what we have got at present is about as close as you can get without breaching the spirit of that," said Ross Walker, UK economist at Royal Bank of Scotland.

Other economists only see a chance of more stimulus once Mark Carney - currently Canada's central bank chief - becomes governor of the BoE in July.

Carney is believed to favour other ways to help the economy such as long-term promises of low interest rates.

British inflation has mostly been above target since the start of the financial crisis due to one-off price shocks - for example, higher sales tax - and the Bank's desire to avoid a surge in unemployment by tightening policy prematurely.

Inflation rose to 2.8 percent in February, and the bank does not forecast it to fall below 2 percent until early 2016.

However, the economy has been stagnant over the past two years. After a 0.3 percent contraction in the last three months of 2012, it risks tipping into its third recession in less than five years.

That risk will be greater if a survey of the service sector in March, due at 0830 GMT(09:30 a.m. British time), shows the same decline as its counterparts for manufacturing and construction published earlier this week.

These conflicting pressures from high inflation and very weak growth help explain why the Bank's nine-member Monetary Policy Committee has been unusually split at its past two meetings.

Bank's Governor Mervyn King, markets expert Paul Fisher, and external MPC member David Miles all voted for an extra 25 billion pounds of bond purchases, but failed to convince their other six peers.

Walker said he expected the impasse to continue. "If there wasn't enough to budge them in February, there's not enough to make them move tomorrow."

March's policy minutes did not suggest either camp's position was softening. Indeed some opposed to more stimulus saw a new reason: the danger that looser monetary policy could trigger a further slide in sterling.

Last month sterling hit a two-and-a-half year low against the dollar and was some 8 percent down since the start of the year, until the minutes and comments from King that the currency was fairly valued helped stem its slide.

However a slim majority of economists think the Bank will restart asset purchases - perhaps as soon as May, when fresh quarterly economic forecasts may sway waverers.

Failing that, the next milestone will the change of leadership at the Bank at the end of June.

"More stimulus should be on its way soon - although we may have to wait for Mr Carney to arrive first," said Vicky Redwood, UK economist at Capital Economics.

(editing by Ron Askew)


View the original article here

Chủ Nhật, 17 tháng 3, 2013

Madeleine Albright: Foreign Policy Has Become 'Much Harder'

After a roundtable appearance on "This Week," former Secretary of State Madeleine Albright joined Martha Raddatz for an ABC News web exclusive. Albright discussed her career, gave advice for the current Secretary of State John Kerry, and talked about how U.S. foreign policy has changed since she served in the Clinton administration.

"I think that in many ways it's gotten much harder because we have this evolution of what we call 'non-state actors.' Various, obviously, terrorist groups that roam around. It's very hard to figure out what tools to use against them. And lack of faith, frankly, in the various international institutions that exist. It's uncharted waters in many ways."

See more of Albright's responses to viewer questions from Facebook and Twitter below:

Are you and Mrs. Clinton friends? Did you offer her any input during her time as our secretary of state?

"Absolutely…when she was first lady and I was secretary we did a lot of tag team stuff together. Traveling abroad. She was one of America's great ambassadors. All her skills were put to work. I thought she was a fantastic secretary of state."

Would Hillary Clinton run for president?

"I have no idea."

Is there anything she would like to go back and change?

"I would like to change something that happened when I was ambassador at the UN was our lack of help in Rwanda. I think we all think about that. I also do wish that we had been able to have Middle East peace that President Clinton worked so hard on."

What one key piece of advice would you like to give Secretary Kerry?

"Well, to understand what it is to represent the United States-that it's the greatest honor to be able to sit behind a sign that says "United States" and be able to use the goodness of American power to make a difference."

Lightning Round:

iPhone or Blackberry?

"Both"

Favorite movie of the year?

"'Lincoln.' Second place, 'Argo'"

Comfort food?

"Frozen Yogurt."

Like "This Week" on Facebook here. You can also follow the show on Twitter here.

Also Read

View the original article here